Top 10 best rated cheap  Broiler Pans reviews to buy

Best Broiler Pans to Buy in 2020 [Updated]

Last updated: Jun 27, 2020 By Jamie


top rated Models tested 35 Models Considered
hours of research 46 Hours of Research
experts interviewed 11 Experts Interviewed
best Reviews Analyzed 92 Reviews Analyzed

If you’re questioning, what is the Best Broiler Pans for Daily Use? You’re at right place. Well finding the good one isn’t an easy task. So we’ve consulted top experts who has in and out knowledge about it. After testing a couple of products, our team listed down top 10 valuable items which performed a lot better than the rest hundreds of options.

Our team spent tons of hours in order to find out the best option available right now in the USA market. An increasingly popular option is a Granite Ware 3-Piece, which is unbeatable in case of reliability and performance. However, if you have a low budget or wanna save some bucks, you can check out Range Kleen Broil and Bake. In both, you’ll get all those features which you expect in Broiler Pans.

To ease your work and save your time, we created a comparison table of Top 10 Best Selling Broiler Pans. All the products are sort based on expert’s reviews.

Top 10 Best Broiler Pans Reviewed : Top Selling in USA 2020


1st Place

Granite Ware 3-Piece
Granite Ware 3-Piece

By Granite Ware

9. 7

Check Price

Best Value

Range Kleen Broil and Bake
Range Kleen Broil and Bake

By Range Kleen

9. 5

Check Price
Norpro Stainless Steel
Norpro Stainless Steel

By Norpro

9. 1

Check Price
OvenStuff Toaster Oven
OvenStuff Toaster Oven

By G & S Metal Products Company

8. 8

Check Price
Nordic Ware Nonstick
Nordic Ware Nonstick

By Nordic Ware

8. 6

Check Price
SmartChoice Basic
SmartChoice Basic

By SmartChoice

8. 2

Check Price
Handi-Foil Disposable
Handi-Foil Disposable

By Handi-Foil

8. 0

Check Price
Sur La Table Stainless Steel
Sur La Table Stainless Steel

By Sur La Table

7 .7

Check Price
Wilton Recipe Right
Wilton Recipe Right

By Wilton

7. 4

Check Price

Check Price

Top 10 Best rated Broiler Pans in USA 2020 : Read Detailed Reviews

For convenience, we have listed down the Top 10 Best Broiler Pans of 2020 which we reviewed.

After investing a lot of time, here we list down top Best Broiler Pans with their Key Features. All of them are crushing the USA market. Without any further delay, let’s check them out:-

#1 Granite Ware 3-Piece – Best & Top rated Broiler Pans

Size:3 pc Set  |  Style Name:Bake, Broil, and Grill Set  |  Color:Black Granite Ware Bake, Broil and Grill set uses the same great Porcelain on Steel construction used in our famous Granite Ware Roasters Porcelain on steel construction is stronger and safer than foil type pans Porcelain is fused to the steel at 2000 degrees Fahrenheit producing a non-porous, inert surface that is naturally non-stick and dishwasher safe.

best Granite Ware 3-Piece reviews
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • Granite ware bake and broil set is made in usa
  • Carbon steel core is more energy efficient browns better and cooks more evenly
  • Porcelain enamel surface is an inert non porous and naturally non stick surface
  • Our roasters and baking pans have no pfoa ptfe or other harmful chemicals and are dishwasher safe
  • Size 9l x 14w x 2h

#2 Range Kleen Broil and Bake Broiler Pans 2020

Size:1 Pack Space-age Kleen Koat porcelain stick-free for easy clean up Dishwasher safe Compact size 8-1/2″ x 13″ x 1-1/2″ Perfect for campers, boats, select toaster ovens, and smaller ranges Ideal size for cakes, desserts, lasagna, etc.

cheap Range Kleen Broil and Bake 2020
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • Cooking done right make the perfect meals with the help of the range kleen bp106x 2 piece heavy duty porcelain broil and bake pan. whether it is broiling meats to perfection or baking dishes cook with ease with this 2 piece utensil.
  • Made from high quality materials heavy duty porcelain on steel grill and base this usa made set is safe for use for up to 1025 degrees f and has oem original equipment manufacturer quality.
  • Good features for broiling and baking the grate of the grill allows fat drippings to drain away from meats. the range kleen bp106x is suitable for use on an outdoor grill and perfect for fish meats and veggies.
  • Cook and clean with ease the materials are easy to clean and dishwasher safe.
  • A welcome addition for any kitchen dimensions 12.75 by 8.5 by 1.325. the broiler pan can be used as a baking dish.

#3 Norpro Stainless Steel

Norpro 273 12″ X 9″ Petite Broiler Set Perforated top allows grease to drain off while you cook Hand washing recommended Constructed of stainless steel for strength and durability The product is from Taiwan.

powerful Norpro Stainless Steel
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • Measures 12 x 9 x 1.5 30.5cm x 23cm x 4cm
  • This two piece stainless steel broiler pan with perforated top allows for grease to drain off while you cook for healthier results.
  • Made of stainless steel for strength and durability. easy to clean.
  • Perfect for individual or two person servings.
  • Ideal for use with rib and loin cuts of meat boneless chicken fish shellfish vegetables and breads.

#4 OvenStuff Toaster Oven 2020

You may also like to read about Best Desk Treadmills

reliable OvenStuff Toaster Oven
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • Two piece value set our personal size baking pan set includes one 8.5 inch by 6.5 inch bake and roast pan and one 8.5 inch by 6.5 inch fat a way broil pan
  • Healthy cooking made easy the fat a way broil pan makes it easy to eliminate excess fat from food such as bacon chicken or fish. grease and fat drip through the holes of the pan as your food bakes leaving you with a healthier meal
  • Non stick finish our proprietary duraglide plus non stick coating keeps you healthier by eliminating the need for cooking spray or oil and makes cleanup easy.
  • Quality steel construction our heavyweight steel construction ensures even heating across the pan for perfect baking results. no more burnt edges
  • American made ovenstuff bakeware is proudly made in the usa.

#5 Nordic Ware Nonstick Cheap and affordable

The OvenStuff Non-Stick Toaster Oven Bake, Broil and Roast Set comes with one 85-inch by 65-inch bake and roast pan and one 85-inch by 65-inch Fat-A-Way broil pan Our Fat-A-Way broil pan makes it easy to prepare healthy, single-serving meals by eliminating excess fat from meats such as bacon, chicken, or fish.

top selling Nordic Ware Nonstick
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • 2 piece broiler pan set for broiling poultry fish or vegetables
  • Includes ribbed broiling rack and a multi purpose bakingdrip pan
  • Measures 15 x 10 x 1 inches
  • Cooking surface l 12.63 inch w 8.38 inch h 0.75 inch

#6 SmartChoice Basic

The Nordic Ware Broiler Pan Set is a state-of-the-art pan carefully designed to meet any broiling needs This pan’s specially formulated, tri-ply construction encases a carbon steel core with two layers of aluminum for quick and even heating and efficient heat retention, and its non-stick coating allows for easy use and cleanup.

top best SmartChoice Basic
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • Nonstick broiler pan for easy clean up
  • Bottom tray can be used separately for roastingbaking
  • More even heat distribution
  • Works well with almost all ovens
  • Healthier cooking

#7 Handi-Foil Disposable

We sell only OEM GE WB48X10056 on this listing Why choose cheap when you can purchase OEM!.

buy Handi-Foil Disposable
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • Top out dimensions 13 x 9 58
  • Top in dimensions 11 12 x 8 12
  • Bottom dimensions 11 18 x 8 12
  • Vertical depth 1 516
  • Capacity fl.oz 54.0

#8 Sur La Table Stainless Steel

You may also like to read about Best Stilts

mini Sur La Table Stainless Steel
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • Sturdy stainless steel broiling pans withstand the high temperatures of broiling and clean up in the dishwasher
  • Bottom trays can be used separately for roasting or baking
  • Two pieces

#9 Wilton Recipe Right

Package Quantity:25 Handi-Foil 13″ x 9″ disposable aluminum foil broiler pan (See precise dimensions listed above) These pans are ideal for broiling, catching grease, keeping oils from food No more messy clean-ups Simply use one time and discard Nice medium size pan OU Kosher certified Proudly made in the USA by Handi-Foil of America.

best Wilton Recipe Right reviews
Key Features
  • Make sure this fits by entering your model number.
  • A healthier way this 2 piece set is designed to let the fat drain away from your meatloaf roast or other meats and into the bottom pan for a less greasy and healthier dish.
  • Non stick surface features steel construction with a non stick surface that provides a quick and clean release of your tasty treats and makes cleanup a breeze.
  • Generous size the 14 x 11 inch size is great for the family. plenty of room for a couple of large steaks or a ton of roasted vegetables.
  • Use and care instructions this baking pan is dishwasher safe however for best results hand wash in warm soapy water before first and after each use. rinse and dry thoroughly with a soft cloth. each pan is covered by wiltons limited 5 year warranty see seller for further details.
  • Everyone everywhere every day innovative products. mouthwatering inspiration. fun in the kitchen. this has been at the heart of what we do for nearly 90 years. whether youre hosting a party or need to bring a special treat wilton has you covered.


This broiler pan by Wilton is a healthy way to cook meats, roasts, fish and chicken This large two-piece broiler pan set lets grease drain off while cooking, so you still get delicious flavor without all the fat Cook up Bacon-Wrapped Shrimp, your favorite cuts of steak, chicken or even Buffalo Wings.

best selling
Key Features

Buying Guide: How to Buy the Best Broiler Pans

Figuring out the type of Broiler Pans to select and what features to look for is pretty straightforward if you have an idea of what you want in your daily uses. Whether or not you know the type you want to buy, here are a few things you should consider before buying any model.

Below, we have gathered all the necessary information required to analyze Broiler Pans as per your requirements.

1. Quality and Durabiity

It is important to check the durability and quality of the material used in it. Since you’re going to use the Broiler Pans for a long time, make sure that the overall build quality is awesome. It should be sturdy, rust proof and should not be flimsy.

2. Brand Reputation

Customer’s reviews and buyer’s satisfaction tell a lot about how well the Broiler Pans performs. When we look at what customers have to say about each of the model, we can get a clear idea of how they perform. Customer reviews can also alert us to any problems people faced and can highlight additional features.

However, you will find a few main brands that are dominating the Broiler Pans market. These brands not only stand above the others, but have a reputation for creating quality products. We dug into the consumer reviews for models made by each brand to get a clearer idea of what customers think about their products.

3. Value for Money

The cheapest Broiler Pans tend to break on impact or fall apart quickly. The most expensive ones may have good performance or might be the incredible among all. A good Broiler Pans does a good job without costing a lot.

4. Warranty

It is always suggested to buy Broiler Pans with a warranty period as you can always replace it with a new product if you find any fault in the device. If not warranty, you should check for return policy so that you do not waste your money on a product that is not effective enough.

How we Tested?

It’s easy to test and review six-seven products alone, but to test more we need a team. We have team of experts and professionals who conduct tests and review each unit. Here are some steps which we follows:

1. Make a List

We don’t want to waste time on testing those products which aren’t available in United States market. So first of all we list down all the products which are in available in the market.

2. Sort out the Best selling # in USA

A tons of models are available in USA. To further break them down, we select those which are top selling and crushing the market right now. For that we do some online research and also forward the list to some trusted store’s owners. It take a couple of days to get complete.

3. Apply Filters

Filters always make it easy for us to find best, isn’t it? So we applied couple of filters like Popularity among customers, Features, Brand Trustness, Price, Durability, and many more. And finally we give the sorted products to our team to start testing.

4. Assign the Task

We have multiple team squad for distinct types of testing, like separate team for testing strength, performance, durability. The Manager assign the the task among then. And finally the results get reviewed by experts and sorted down the best ones.


If you are new to purchasing a Broiler Pans, you can surely make a mistake as there are several options available in the market. That is why we have provided guide to you. Read it carefully to make a correct choice and save your money from going waste.

If you’re looking for something even cheaper, the Range Kleen Broil and Bakeis a budget-friendly underdog that keeps up with the pack.

Have a Great Day!